Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Rubio says Ukraine's Starlink access is Musk's call as Trump denies role in slowdown

The Wall Street Journal reported that Musk ordered the slowdown. Trump said he was not involved, and lawmakers from both parties asked for answers.

10 outlets18 headlines3 min read Blindspot for the left
Image: National Review

The story

Ukrainian drone units lost satellite links starting Oct. 13, CBS reported. On Oct. 21, Secretary of State Marco Rubio said Starlink access is up to Elon Musk, four days after he said nobody ordered the slowdown.

  • Problems began around Oct. 13 or 14. A Ukrainian adviser, Serhii Beskrestnov, said SpaceX capped Starshield at 160 km/h, about 100 mph, Al Jazeera reported. Faster drones lost their link.
  • Starshield is the military version of Starlink and uses the same satellites, CBS said.
  • On Oct. 17, Rubio said nobody ordered the slowdown and "it wasn't deliberate," Reuters reported. On Oct. 20, the Wall Street Journal reported that Musk ordered it.
  • On Oct. 21 in Mumbai, Rubio said access is "governed by a private commercial contract," Reuters reported. Trump said, "I don't know who did it but I was not involved," The Hill reported.
  • Reuters, citing three officials, reported that the decision "ultimately came from the White House." The administration denied it.
  • Musk wrote on X that limits "are decided by the US military and ultimately POTUS," the Daily Wire reported.
  • Republican Reps. Brian Fitzpatrick and Don Bacon pressed for answers, The Hill reported. Democratic Reps. Rosa DeLauro and Betty McCollum asked Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth for findings within 30 days, Stars and Stripes reported.
  • The reports we read don't show who gave the technical order.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets gave this story little room. Of the 18 headlines we grouped, CBS News carried the only left-leaning one. CBS ran: "Musk chose to restrict Ukraine's access to SpaceX satellite network, sources say." Its follow-up explainer quoted Musk first, in paragraph 5. In paragraph 19 it said "the U.S. government pays SpaceX to license Starshield and controls access." CBS put Musk's role at the top and the government's role in the middle. Its headline said "sources say," a fair flag that the account was not yet confirmed on the record.

What got buried

The government's own contracts sat lowest. CBS reported in paragraph 29 that SpaceX won a Pentagon contract in 2023 covering 500 Starshield terminals for Ukraine. In paragraph 30 it said an August 2024 Defense Department deal expanded that to 3,000 front-line terminals, citing Bloomberg. Reuters called Starshield "developed for the Pentagon" in paragraph 13 of 14. The Daily Wire, The Hill and National Review gave no contract detail in the versions we read. That detail bears directly on Rubio's "private commercial contract" line.

Why it matters to you

Your tax money is part of this. CBS reported that the US government pays SpaceX to license Starshield and controls access to it. The terminal count under Pentagon deals went from 500 in 2023 to 3,000 in 2024, CBS said. That is six times as many. One analyst put Ukraine's losses from the slowdown in the tens of millions of dollars, CBS reported. If the government pays for the service, then who limited it is a question about public money. You can ask one plain question of any follow-up story: which contract, and who signed it.

When everyone points elsewhere, follow the contract.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.