Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Ramaswamy campaign says it made ad with Acton's estranged mother, plans $4 million buy

Some Ohio Republicans criticized the ad, and Vance told them to stop. Left outlets led with the backlash, right outlets with the mother's words.

14 outlets16 headlines2 min read
Image: Associated Press (via AJC)

The story

Vivek Ramaswamy's campaign will spend $4 million on TV and streaming for a one-minute ad, AP reported. In it, Democrat Amy Acton's mother says, "She is a liar."

  • The ad surfaced around Oct. 19 with no "paid for" line. On Oct. 20 Ramaswamy said, "It is an ad from our campaign," CNN reported.
  • In it, Donna Arthur, Acton's mother, tells Ohioans, "Don't vote for people who lie." She disputes Acton's account of a hard childhood.
  • AP cited police and court records. Acton's stepfather was arrested in July 1978 for raping her when she was 12. He was indicted that September and was a fugitive until at least 1981.
  • Acton told Spectrum News, "I won't normalize somebody," AP reported. Her brother, Philip Stearns, said their mother stayed married to the stepfather until he died.
  • Republican Sen. Jon Husted said, "I would not have run that ad," CNN reported. Vice President JD Vance told critics to "stop whining about an advertisement."
  • Ramaswamy said Arthur was "not compensated," CNN reported.
  • A Marist poll taken Oct. 15 to 18 put Acton at 50% and Ramaswamy at 43% among likely voters. The margin of error was 4.5 points.
  • More than 676,000 Ohioans had already voted, AP reported. The election is Nov. 3.

How each side told it

The left led with the backlash. CNN ran: "Key Ohio Republicans criticize Ramaswamy's ad with Acton's estranged mother." Its first quote came from Husted, a Republican, in paragraph 2. Vance's defense followed in paragraphs 6 and 7. CNN put the 1978 court records last, in paragraphs 41 to 44. HuffPost's headline called Arthur "Amy Acton's Pedophile-Protecting Mother." The New York Times headline said the ad made the race "Even Uglier." We read CNN in full and saw the HuffPost and Times headlines only.

What got buried

The mother's own record appeared almost nowhere. PolitiFact, a fact-check site, reported Pennsylvania records in paragraphs 18 and 19. They show a 1996 felony conviction for theft by deception that included Arthur, it said. She was convicted of animal neglect in 2021, and an appeals court vacated that in 2023. In the seven reports we read, only PolitiFact mentioned either. AP put the 1978 rape records in paragraphs 13 and 14. TheBlaze and the Daily Wire cited no court records at all.

Why it matters to you

This ad asks you to judge a candidate's childhood. Public records can help you do that. The 1978 indictment ran in the Youngstown Vindicator, PolitiFact reported. The Marist lead of 7 points sits outside the 4.5-point margin, but polls can move in two weeks. The $4 million buy works out to about $286,000 a day over the final 14 days. That money buys repeat views in your feed and on TV. If you vote in Ohio, you can read the court records before the ad reaches you a fifth time.

The louder the accusation, the more the court record matters.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.