Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Judge grills Trump officials over plan to close a public DC golf course for 15 months

Judge Ana Reyes questioned the removal of up to 529 trees. Eleven outlets in our list covered the Oct. 19 hearing, and none of them lean right.

11 outlets14 headlines2 min read Blindspot for the right
Image: ABC News (via ABC7)

The story

A 106-year-old public golf course in Washington could close for about 15 months starting Nov. 15, AP reported. On Oct. 19, a federal judge spent nearly seven hours asking why.

  • In February, the D.C. Preservation League and two golfers sued the Interior Department and the National Park Service, AP and NPR reported. They said the overhaul would raise tee-time costs at a park "open to all people."
  • In May, Judge Ana C. Reyes required notice before major work, including removing more than 10 trees, NPR reported.
  • On Oct. 9, the government said it would remove "up to 529 trees" in phases. Bulldozers started the next day, NPR reported. ABC put the count at over 500, and Fox News at about 430.
  • Reyes then paused the work until at least Oct. 26. On Oct. 18, she denied a Justice Department request that she step aside, AP reported.
  • That day, Trump posted that work would start Nov. 15. A Justice Department filing said there was no final plan, AP reported.
  • Hours before the Oct. 19 hearing, Trump called Reyes "a crazed lunatic," Fox News reported.
  • In court, Reyes said: "There is no universe in which all of this coincidentally happened," AP reported. Interior officials said a 2019 planning report drove the tree cutting.
  • The hearing ended with no ruling, NPR reported.

How each side told it

The left led with the judge's anger. NPR ran: "Judge chastises Trump administration plan to push ahead overhaul of DC golf course." It quoted Reyes first and put Trump's attack in paragraph 10. ABC ran: "DOJ official clashes with judge in DC golf course case after Trump attacks her." It opened on the clash, quoted Reyes on "bad faith" first and put Trump's post in paragraph 12. CNN's headline used Trump's own phrase, "trash island." Neither NPR nor ABC gave a dollar figure for fees or for the renovation.

What got buried

Who uses the course, and what it costs, sat low everywhere. AP raised affordability in paragraph 14, with no numbers. NPR named the cyclists, runners and anglers who use the park in paragraph 11. ABC and Fox News left affordability out. In the five reports we read, none gave the green fee, the renovation cost or who pays for it. The plaintiffs sued over price, and the price stayed out of the stories.

Why it matters to you

If you golf there, you may lose the course for about 15 months, AP reported. The New York Times put it closer to 14. The plaintiffs say prices would rise once it reopens. The reports we read don't give today's fee or a new one, so the math can't be done yet. If you bike, run or fish in the park, NPR reported the fight touches you too. The tree count runs from 430 to 529, depending on the outlet. The earliest the pause can end is Oct. 26. The judge's ruling decides when work starts.

The first question about any project is who pays.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.