Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Obama calls probe of Rep. Ilhan Omar "appalling" as Homan raises denaturalization

Agents searched Omar's DC home on Oct. 12 over her citizenship papers. She has not been charged, and officials have not disclosed evidence.

11 outlets15 headlines2 min read
Image: Sinclair National News Desk

The story

Barack Obama called the federal investigation of Rep. Ilhan Omar "so appalling" on Oct. 18. Omar has not been charged with any crime, CNN and CBS News reported.

  • On Monday, Oct. 12, Homeland Security Investigations agents searched Omar's home in Washington, DC. They are working with the Justice Department.
  • Agents seized her phone, CBS News reported. The New York Times reported they left with "several boxes of seized items."
  • The question is whether Omar's father lied about her age when she became a citizen in 2000. If she was 18, she could not have become a citizen through him, the Times reported.
  • Investigators also reviewed family text messages from a phone seized earlier from her sister, Sahra Noor. Those messages helped persuade a judge to approve the search, the Times reported.
  • On Oct. 16, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin called it "a strong case," CBS reported.
  • On Oct. 18, Obama posted a long statement on X. He said the probe "should outrage all Americans."
  • Omar said, "I will not be silenced." Her lawyers called the search unconstitutional.
  • Border czar Tom Homan later told Fox that Omar could lose her citizenship and be deported if fraud is proven.
  • The Justice Department has not disclosed any evidence, CNN reported.

How each side told it

The left led with Obama. NBC News ran: "Obama calls Trump officials' investigation of Ilhan Omar 'appalling'." In the CNN version we read, Obama was quoted first. The search and the age question came in paragraph 3. Paragraph 7 said Omar has not been charged. CNN did not mention Mullin's "strong case" or the messages from her sister's phone. The New York Times had reported those messages the day before. MS NOW's headline used a phrase from Rep. Castro: "Raid a critic, pay a crony."

What got buried

The election calendar sat at the bottom. The search broke the Justice Department's usual caution in the 60 days before an election, CNN reported. That was paragraph 11, its last. The Times version we read put it in paragraph 12. Fox News did not mention it in the version we read. A second detail came from CBS News in paragraph 7. The racketeering law Mullin floated usually carries a 5-year time limit.

Why it matters to you

This case tests how far back a citizenship check can reach. Omar became a citizen in 2000 after fleeing Somalia in 1995, CNN reported. That is 26 years before this search. Homan has said that if officials prove someone lied to become a citizen, they can "absolutely denaturalize them." He also called it a long process, the Daily Wire reported. The reports we read did not cite the specific law. No charge has been filed, so no court has tested the evidence. If you or your parents naturalized, this is the case to follow.

An investigation is a question, and only a court answers it.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.